Sign up now for ease of access to The Medical Independent, Ireland’s most frequently published medical newspaper, delivering award-winning news and investigative reporting.

  • receive the eCopy two days prior to the printed edition.
  • can partake in our online MCQs.
  • can enter our online sports quiz.


Medicalindependent.ie is Ireland's only investigative medical news website for doctors, healthcare professionals and anyone with an interest in health issues.

Established in 2010, along with its sister publication The Medical Independent, our stated aim is to investigate and analyse the major issues affecting healthcare and the medical profession in Ireland. The Medical Independent has won a number of awards for its investigative journalism, and its stories are frequently picked up by national digital, broadcast and print media. The Medical Independent is published by GreenCross Publishing.

Address: Top Floor, 111 Rathmines Road Lr, Dublin 6

Tel: 353 (01) 441 0024

GreenCross Publishing is owned by Graham Cooke.

You are reading 1 of 2 free-access articles allowed for 30 days

Drive to improve CUH orthopaedic trauma services

By Mindo - 01st Mar 2018 | 40 views

<p class=”p1″><span class=”s1″><em>National Model of Care for Trauma and Orthopae</em></span><span class=”s2″><em>dic Surgery </em>was launched in July 2015 by the then Min</span>ister for Health Leo Varadkar in a bid to standardise ser<span class=”s1″>vices across the country. According to the Model, there</span>

<p class=”p2″><span class=”s1″>is significant scope for treating more patients within the cur</span>rent system by standardising treatment pathways and ensur- ing that appropriate facilities are designated at the right time <span class=”s1″>to the right patient. At the time, the document noted, interven</span><span class=”s2″>tions taking place at an orthopaedic outpatient clinic could vary </span><span class=”s1″>from a relatively short time requirement for fracture diagnosis </span><span class=”s2″>and treatment, to a considerable time requirement for complex </span><span class=”s1″>cases, or for explanation of diagnosis and treatment options to </span>patients and agreement on the treatment plan.

<p class=”p2″><span class=”s1″>In many hospitals, orthopaedic outpatient clinics had large </span>attendance figures and also frequently overran the expected <span class=”s1″>timeframe in terms of appointments, resulting in lengthy de- </span>lays for patients and inefficient service delivery.

<p class=”p2″>According to the document, there are many ways in which <span class=”s1″>to improve the delivery of care to trauma and orthopaedic patients. The Model states that there must be timely access to radiology examinations and other diagnostic investigations on an outpatient basis, while designated and protected beds, both for inpatients and day cases, where possible, must be </span>made available. Admitting patients as inpatients is inappropriate when the procedure could be performed as a day case, the Model states.

<h3 class=”p3″>CUH orthopaedic trauma service</h3> <p class=”p2″><span class=”s1″>As with most health service plans, implementation of the Model has been variable across different hospitals. A report produced by Cork University Hospital (CUH), obtained by the <strong><em>Medical Independent </em></strong>(<strong><em>MI</em></strong>), outlines the continued problems with the orthopaedic trauma service in the hospital, while producing recommendations to resolve these problems. Written by the hospital’s CEO, Mr Tony McNamara, the report was issued to the Orthopaedic Trauma Group and </span>the Executive Management Board of CUH.

<p class=”p2″><span class=”s1″>The report acknowledges the trauma department in the </span>hospital is extremely busy. In the period January to October <span class=”s1″>2017 the service had 20,839 outpatients; 2,092 inpatient dis</span>charges; and 274 day case discharges. It had an average pre-<span class=”s1″>operative length of stay of 2.06 days and an average post-op</span>erative length of stay of 6.79.

<p class=”p2″><span class=”s1″>The report states that in 2017 recognition of the need for a change in the clinical pathway for unscheduled (emergency) patients led to the implementation of various initiatives to improve clinical pathways in CUH’s orthopaedic trauma service.</span>

<p class=”p2″><span class=”s1″>The implementation of a patient flow plan (PF17) has brought a reduction in the number of trolleys in the hospi</span>tal’s emergency department (ED).

<p class=”p2″><span class=”s1″>“In addition, since many orthopaedic trauma patients are >75 [years] and pose particular care and placement challenges for the hospital, it is important to note the progress made by PF17 in working towards sustained improvements in the management of this cohort of patients towards the stated ambition in PF17 of having no patient >75 years old waiting </span>more than nine hours for a bed,” it states.

<p class=”p2″>The report also acknowledges the 2015 National Model of <span class=”s1″>Care as a “driver for change”, noting the Model sets out a small </span>number of key indicators that are germane to the work of the <span class=”s1″>CUH group specifically.</span>

<p class=”p2″><span class=”s1″>These measurements include the percentage of patients admitted to the orthopaedic ward within four hours of admission to the ED; the percentage of patients sent to surgery within 48 hours; and the percentage of patients seen </span>preoperatively by a geriatrician.

<p class=”p2″><span class=”s1″>“Measured against these standards, CUH does not per</span>form well and suggests the need for a quality improvement <span class=”s1″>programme, which the governance group is charged with </span>developing.”

<p class=”p2″>In respect to patients admitted to a ward within four hours <span class=”s1″>of presentation at the ED, in 2016 less than two per cent of patients met this target in CUH against a national average of 14.4 per cent.</span>

<p class=”p2″>Also, only half of the orthopaedic trauma patients in CUH <span class=”s1″>had their surgery performed within the recommended 48-hour period, against a national average of almost 73 per cent. The report states that the performance of the hospital </span>in this regard is “suboptimal”.

<p class=”p2″><span class=”s1″>“This data is presented, not in any way to apportion blame, </span>but to highlight that the system is in urgent need to reform, that process need to change and that leadership at all levels have both responsibility and an opportunity to make a real <span class=”s1″>contribution to improving the care and lives of these vulnerable patients.”</span>

<p class=”p1″><span class=”s2″>There are other issues that require change in the patient path</span><span class=”s1″>way and in the responsiveness of the hospital’s systems to sup</span><span class=”s2″>port this pathway. These include the availability of NIQUIS [Na</span>tional Quality Assurance and Improvement System] data that allows comparison between the performance of the service in CUH relative to national norms. Another key issue is “the ex- <span class=”s1″>traordinary levels of cancellation of patients scheduled for operation that is suboptimal in terms of patient care and reputationally damaging to the service and to the hospital”.</span>

<p class=”p2″><span class=”s1″>In September 2017 CUH’s Executive Management Board </span>with the support of the surgical directorate and the department of orthopaedics established a structured review of the <span class=”s1″>orthopaedic trauma service and the report includes a summa</span>ry of their recommendations. The recommendations, which were developed by three sub-groups, are broken down into <span class=”s1″>ED presentation/admission procedures; theatre management processes; and discharge planning.</span>

<h3 class=”p2″>Recommendations</h3> <p class=”p1″><span class=”s1″><strong><em>Emergency department</em></strong></span>

<p class=”p1″>In terms of ED presentations, the report recommends <span class=”s1″>that patients presenting with a fractured hip will be seen by the ED medical team and using a pro-forma pathway mod</span>elled on the Canterbury hip fracture pathway, will have a <span class=”s1″>determination made by that team as to admission status. In </span>order to aid rapid patient flow and to help achieve the tar<span class=”s1″>get of the national programme of having patients in an orthopaedic ward within four hours, it will be necessary to review the organisation and allocation of orthopaedic beds to facilitate consolidation in a single area. This might take the form of a dedicated orthopaedic ward with additional beds in the adjacent ward or a dedicated trauma floor to include </span>orthopaedic and plastic trauma beds. Also, the report states that the number of orthopaedic trau<span class=”s1″>ma beds to be allocated will need to be determined since effi</span>ciencies in the management of those patients, following rec<span class=”s1″>ommendations of the review, will reduce the number of beds required from the present number of 50, which is the average number of beds used, but can raise to 70 beds at times of peak </span>demand. Following the consolidation of beds, the report ar<span class=”s1″>gues the goal must be to maintain one or two beds in anticipation of hip fracture patients presenting to be managed by the orthopaedic team in consultation with the clinical nurse man</span>ager and bed management. This model already exists on one <span class=”s1″>of the hospital’s wards. Also a new pathway was recommended to fast-track hip fracture patients to these beds.</span>

<p class=”p1″><span class=”s1″><strong><em>Theatre management processes</em></strong></span>

<p class=”p1″><span class=”s1″>According to the report, there is a consensus that much can </span>be done to improve patient flow between wards and theatre and within the theatre complex itself. It points out that this is best indicated by the number of patients reported as “can<span class=”s1″>celled”, a process which often takes place despite patients being prepared for theatre.</span>

<h3 class=”p3″>Cork University Hospital</h3> <p class=”p1″><span class=”s1″>“Addressing the causes of the sub-optimality in theatre is a complex challenge involving issues as diverse as rosters, </span>use of management information, process improvements <span class=”s1″>and most of all leadership at multiple levels.”</span>

<p class=”p1″>In respect of arrangements for surgical and nursing staff in <span class=”s1″>theatre, the report states there is a need for new rosters such that each consultant orthopaedic surgeon would work three or four days on-call, during which time they do not have other duties.</span>

<p class=”p1″>“This will provide for much needed continuity, casemix and scheduling oversight, governance and clinical leader<span class=”s1″>ship in the orthopaedic theatre.”</span>

<p class=”p1″>Nurse recruitment should be prioritised with the inten<span class=”s1″>tion of developing a 24/7 on-site roster for the orthopaedic </span>service with better continuity and increased on-site pres<span class=”s1″>ence. Another recommendation is to implement scheduling arrangements to maximise the use of two theatres and the “block room” to increase patient throughput and to reduce the intra-operative time between cases. The report also recommends recommencing discussion on enhancing the role of portering staff in theatre by developing the theatre assistant grade and upskilling staff appropriately.</span>

<p class=”p1″><span class=”s1″><strong><em>Discharge planning</em></strong></span>

<p class=”p1″>The average post-operative length of stay for patients in the <span class=”s1″>CUH orthopaedic service is 6.79 days. According to the report, there are many reasons for this that are specific to CUH and are a result of “sub-optimality” in the transfer of patients for rehabilitation to other settings and the processes for discharge.</span>

<p class=”p1″><span class=”s1″>“It is clear that <em>prima facie</em>, there is a significant opportunity to save bed days by improving these processes,” according to the report.</span>

<p class=”p1″>To achieve improvements to discharge planning, it is recommended that new arrangements are implemented to consolidate orthopaedic trauma (and perhaps all trauma patients) in a single area to increase specialisation in <span class=”s1″>the management of these patients. It is also recommended that an ortho-geriatrician should be appointed to work be</span>tween CUH and South Infirmary Victoria University Hospital (SIVUH), Cork, on pathways for transfer, optimisation of protocols and interface with community services. <span class=”s1″>The report also suggests ascertaining with colleagues in the community the possibility of having two convalescent beds ringfenced for orthopaedic trauma patients in Cork. Another recommendation is for the appointment of an advanced nurse practitioner for orthopaedic trauma services.</span>

<h3 class=”p2″>Resources and next steps</h3> <p class=”p1″><span class=”s1″>The CUH report states that implementing the recommendations represents a “very challenging” programme of work. However, it adds that if implemented successfully, these reforms have the potential to make a substantial contribution to the delivery of orthopaedic trauma services, but also to the performance and reputation of CUH.</span>

<p class=”p1″>While many of the recommendations can be achieved by means of an internal reorganisation of resources and changing work practices, the report does stress that some <span class=”s1″>initiatives will need additional financing.</span>

<p class=”p1″><span class=”s1″>Now that the recommendations have been approved, the governing group will oversee the recommendations and the sub-groups will be maintained to assist with the process.</span>

<p class=”p1″>“These recommendations offer a unique opportunity to improve patient flow for orthopaedic trauma patients and <span class=”s1″>in the process, to use the resources of the orthopaedic and </span>related services in CUH, SIVUH and the community to a <span class=”s1″>greater extent than the existing pathways offer,” the report concluded.</span>

<p class=”p1″>“This will require commitments from leadership at all lev<span class=”s1″>els of the service that has been demonstrated in the work of the </span>group to date and it is vitally important that we work in uni- son with the national care programmes, the SSW Group, the <span class=”s1″>Acute Hospitals Directorate and other stakeholders to implement this programme of initiatives.”</span>

<p class=”p1″>A spokesperson for CUH told <strong><em>MI </em></strong>that the report’s recommendations have already yielded benefits. As a result of the report, there was a reorganisation of beds, leading to improvements in patient flow and an improvement in the <span class=”s1″>scheduling of patients for theatre.</span>

Leave a Reply

Latest
Latest Issue
medical news
The Medical Independent 19th May 2022

You need to be logged in to access this content. Please login or sign up using the links below.

Most Read